I may like it if the pieces were smaller.' 7/10Įrica: 'I actually don't mind this combination! But there just seems to be something off taste-wise, I can't put my butterfinger on it.' 9.5/10īrooklynn: 'Just too much finger and chocolate, it's over powering the popcorn.' 7/10Īverage Rating: 7.8/10 5. Now this concoction was a little outside of the box, so I though this would be the perfect place to try it out.īrooke: 'The ratio of popcorn to chocolate isn't balanced. I couldn't have a tasting with out adding the original popcorn filler, M&M's.īrooke: 'This one is perfect because it is all chocolate!' 9/10Įrica: 'One of the best ones if not the best! There are no gimmicks, just classic chocolate' 9/10īrooklynn: 'I love how this is simply chocolate and popcorn, timeless and classic.' 9/10Īverage Rating: 9/10 4. Though the classic partner for popcorn is regular M&M's, why not add a modern spin by adding peanuts to the party.īrooke: 'Wow! This combination is like a flavor explosion in my mouth!' 10/10Įrica: 'Perfect size of chocolate, creating an exceptional balance between sweet and salty.' 10/10īrooklynn: 'Wow this one is really good! Like, welcome to Willy Wonka!' 10/10 The peanut butter adds a little something extra!' 8/10Īverage Rating: 8/10 2. Reese's Pieces Brooke Billingsįirst up was Reese's Pieces, a fun sized version of the ever classic peanut butter cups.īrooke: 'I like it! The combination is a great marriage of sweet and salty.' 9/10Įrica: 'Not too bad! I could use a little more chocolate, though.' 7/10īrooklynn: 'Very good choice.

I had them one by one taste each chocolate with a hand full of popcorn describing the combination and rating it overall out of 10. To make sure I was getting the highest and most thorough of critiques, I gathered a panel of popcorn experts (and the only people available): Brooke, Erica, and Brooklynn.

Best movie theater popcorn